Skip to main content

Working with Lead Vendors

Updated over a week ago

Getting Started

  • Lead strategy. Leads are an important component of any agent’s growth strategy. We know the big call centers are winning the enrollments game via aggressive lead generation. We give you the same lead opportunities the call centers have -- meaning you’ll have the same enrollment capability, but your unique value prop as a local, independent agent (leading to better retention) is your advantage.

  • The team behind you. Spark is your business partner and back-office. We’ll help you design a strategy for your goals, and we’ll implement & manage vendor campaign.

  • Playing the long-term game. Lastly, you should remember that most prospects you meet won’t be ready to enroll now, if at all. And that’s okay! We are educators and advocates, not salespeople. Every person who doesn't enroll but leaves with a positive impression of you and as a Spark Member should be viewed as a success -- as well as a future enrollment opportunity.

Lead Opportunities

Your lead strategy is made up of inbound and outbound opportunities. We recommend combination of both. See below for the specific lead formats.

Inbound Opportunities

Inbound calls require the least work from you and can generate many enrollments quickly, but they are expensive and require you commit to being available for certain time windows (you get charged for missed calls). We recommend beginning with a small time window and expanding Inbound Opportunities investment once you’ve proven your call close rate and return on investment.

Format

Tell us the hours you'd like to receive calls and the state(s) where you're licensed, and you’ll receive calls periodically throughout your window. No outbound calling is required.

Cost

$55 - 75 per lead, depending on the source

How to work with them

  • Most vendors will charge you for missing a call, while others will only penalize you by increasing the price of future calls. For this reason, we recommend setting aside concentrated periods during which you can receive them.

  • Within <10 seconds of receiving a call, you'll be able to see the lead's key information in a portal associated with the lead gen vendor. You’ll have between 60 - 90 seconds of “buffer” time during which you can further qualify the prospect. If you hang up within that time period, you won’t be charged.

  • Though each conversation will be different, we’ve prepared a general script you can use for appointments here.

What to expect

  • ___% of calls enroll immediately (for plan effective dates within 30 days)

  • Prospects undergo minimal screening (they are determined to be eligible for Medicare within your state) and quality varies widely; sometimes you'll receive calls about home health aides, Medicaid, etc. and prospects will be rushing to receive an answer or may be confused why they are on the phone in the first place. Here are copies of the screening questions and scripts used by the vendors.

  • Many prospects won’t be ready to enroll yet (or at all), and that’s okay -- be helpful anyway! Someone who hasn’t enrolled but has signed up for Spark Member Services should be viewed as a success and an opportunity for the future (we’ll do all the follow-ups for you).

  • For prospects not ready to enroll immediately, establish permission to contact again in 3 months, always answer any questions they have for free (and bring in your Spark Navigator team for extra support where appropriate), ask if they’d like Spark Member Services (TBD).

Follow up

  • In your CRM, you should disposition each lead under:

    • Enrollment: Capturing enrollment data in your CRM will trigger a set of personalized engagements for your client related to the Spark Member Services

    • Prospect (?): Member Services, non-Member Services

Vendors we work with

  • Lead Heroes - priced on a per-campaign basis (around $960 for 2 weeks), which should lead to 2-3 daily calls during a 4 hour window**.**

  • Datalot - great for consistent volume, but will be ~$65 per lead

Outbound Opportunities

We recommend having a steady flow of Outbound Opportunities as part of your marketing mix to keep you busy in the down time between other work. Outbound Opportunities are cheaper, and you can call them on your own time (though best practice is to call them as quickly as possible, within 24 hours at the latest).

Format

You’ll receive the name, date of birth, contact information, and other basic information associated with a "prospect who gave consent to be contacted about Medicare."

Cost

$10 - $30 per lead depending on how the lead was generated. In some cases the data lead can be below $10, especially if it is old or has been shared with other agents already. We recommend never purchasing shared leads. We also offer higher-quality call-verified leads, where the prospect has been told that you'll be calling them within the next few days at an approximate time (morning, afternoon, evening).

How to work with them

  • These leads require you (or your assistant) to dial them shortly after receiving them, and trying them several times over the subsequent days. The longer you hold off on contacting them, the lower your close rate.

  • Our general appointment script here is applicable to these types of opportunities as well.

What to expect

  • It’s important not to get discouraged if you struggle to get in touch with prospects immediately.

  • ___% of opportunities successfully contacted on first call

  • ___% of opportunities successfully contacted over one week period

  • ___% of contacts into appointments or sales in the next 30 days

  • ___% of contacts turned into warm prospects you can follow up with over time (via Member Services)

Follow up

  • Best practice is to call each lead within 24 hours of receiving your information. For leads who don’t pick up, you should leave a voicemail introducing yourself and your unique value prop (Spark script).

  • You should call leads at least once every 24 hours for 3 days until you are able to contact the prospect. If you can, try calling at various times of the day.

  • In addition to calling, you should send text (script) and email (script) follow-ups when possible over the 3-day period after you get the opportunity.

    • Side note: it may be worth exploring additional software to automate this? One agent we talked to mentioned PhoneBurner

  • It’s okay to be persistent! There is a fine line between persistence and pushiness. You should feel proud of the value you can provide your prospect as a local Medicare expert -- if you don’t reach the prospect, someone else who cares less about the consumer might.

Vendors we work with

  • Lead Concepts - pay ~$510 per 1,000 mailers (<2% response)

  • RGI - pay $20 per lead generated (we will have to purchase on your behalf)

  • Select internet vendors, but speak with us in advance.

Recommended Lead Vendors

Mail

RGI Mailer Leads [pay-per-mailer lead]

  • What it is: mailer leads at a set price. Vendor sends out mail campaigns on our behalf and generates leads. The prospects write back requesting more information about Medicare options.

  • Order timeline: for 66+, 2-3 weeks before you want the leads to come // for t65, need to order by the 23rd of the month to receive the following month

  • Format: agent will receive leads to their Spark CRM along with copies of the business reply card emailed to them

  • Quality: high intent since someone has reached out for more information and written a physical request card.

  • Pricing: ~$25 - 35 per lead

  • Example lead:

Lead Concepts (related vendors: Need-A-Lead, ARM) [pay-per-mailer campaign]

  • What it is: you pay for a "mail drop" of 1,000 mailers. From the day you execute the mail drop, you'll start receiving leads ~2-3 weeks later. You can select the specific location and the type of campaign to run.

  • Order timeline: 2-3 weeks

  • Format: agent will receive leads to the vendor's CRM when the first lead comes back. All subsequent leads can be accessed via the CRM. The vendor can also have the business-reply-cards mailed to you.

  • Quality: high intent since someone has reached out for more information and written a physical request card.

  • Pricing: ~$510 per 1,000 leads

Calls

Datalot (related vendors: NextGen, InsideResponse, Quantum Media) [pay-per-call]

  • What it is: these are warm transfers that are purchased per-lead. A call center agent will pass the transfer to our licensed agent. While the prospect should be qualified based on (a) being of appropirate age (b) having Medicare parts and B, in some cases the prospects do not know why they're on the phone or are frustrated about being passed on so frequently. Our agent has 60 seconds to qualify them again. If the prospect stays on for more than 60 seconds, our agent will be charged. If less than 60 seconds, our agent will not be charged. If our agent wants to get off the line quickly, it's fine to say something along the lines of: "Looks like there's nothing to worry about. I hope you have a nice day."

  • Order timeline: you can typically start a new campaign within a few days. You can set specific windows that you have availability.

  • Format: agent will receive calls to their OpenPhone number. In the near future we will have an integration so the agent can see the number directly in their CRM.

  • Quality: high variability; some people need assistance with an issue immediately, others are very frustrated to be on the line.

  • Pricing: ~$65 per lead. You are typically charged if you miss a call.

Lead Heroes [pay-per-call campaign]

  • What it is: a custom call campaign led by an overseas call center that calls compliant leads for you and attempts to make warm transfers. They can run t65 campaigns and Medicare Supplement campaigns. For t65 campaigns, you may speak with people who are more than 6 months out. It's an opportunity to establish trust & expertise with them upfront by refreshing their eligibility requirements.

  • Order timeline: 5 - 10 days in advance of start date

  • Format: these calls are considered "warm transfers". You will be connected with the prospect through the LeadHeroes caller. The data will also be sent to your CRM directly within 30 seconds of the call start. If you miss the transfer, you'll be able to call that person back. Try calling them back 2x the first day, then 1x the next two days.

  • Quality: average with high variability (frustrated to happy callers). While all the screening questions are the same, the client gets to the phone call through different starting channels (e.g. some start on google search, Facebook, mailer, etc.) so has a different level of interest.

  • Pricing: ~$20 - 30 per lead

    • $960 for 80 hours of calling (2 weeks)

    • $1,600 for 160 hours of calling (4 weeks)

    • $3,840 for 480 hours of calling

  • Can select morning (9am - 1pm) or afternoon (1pm - 5pm)

Purchasing T65 Leads

You can purchase T65 leads at https://mutual.usadata.com/

Internet Data Leads

There are several lead vendors, such as NextGen and Leadrilla, but speak to us before you consider any of these. In our experience, mailer leads are much higher intent.

Full List of Lead Vendors

Did this answer your question?